In this article
  1. The scenario
  2. The reflection questions
  3. What police services recommend
  4. What this scenario reveals
  5. Taking your reflection further
  6. Discussing the scenario as a family
  7. Further reading

Extreme situations don’t give warning. This scenario is designed as a mental exercise: it puts you in a high-pressure situation to invite you to reflect on your priorities, your decision logic and the inner resources you would draw on at a critical moment.

There is no universal right or wrong answer. The goal is to stimulate reflection, compare different approaches and strengthen your mental preparedness before a real crisis forces you to.

Code name: Hard choice
Category: Intrusion, direct threat, family pressure
Complexity level: High — strong emotional component

The scenario

You wake in the middle of the night with a sharp pain in your head. As you slowly come to, you realize you have taken a violent blow to the skull. You have been put out of action.

Opening your eyes, you see an armed group ransacking your home. Your spouse and your two children are gagged, tied up and placed against a wall. They can neither cry out nor intervene.

The group’s leader approaches you. He explains clearly that, to make sure you won’t try anything once they have left, he intends to take a member of your family with them. And he leaves it to you to decide which one.

Once they are gone, there is no guarantee you will see that person again.

Editorial note
This scenario is an exercise in reflection and mental preparation. It is not a guide to how to behave in a real criminal situation. In a real situation, the absolute priorities remain the immediate physical safety of everyone present and calling emergency services as soon as possible.

The reflection questions

This scenario invites you to explore several dimensions at once. Before answering instinctively, take the time to examine each of the following questions.

Who would you let go?

Your spouse? One of your children? If so, which one and why? On what basis are you making this decision: age, ability to defend themselves, likelihood of survival, something else?

What is your decision logic?

Is it an emotional decision, a strategic one, or both at once? Are you trying to protect the most vulnerable person, or the one who would have the best chance of getting through?

Is there another option?

Is refusing to choose conceivable? Does it change anything? Is there a way to negotiate, buy time or influence the situation without giving in to the conditions imposed?

After they leave: what do you do?

Free yourself, alert emergency services, take care of the remaining family members — in what order? (Trying to follow or chase an armed group endangers the person taken and yourself: that is the police’s job.) Do you have a plan, or are you improvising entirely?

What police services recommend

When facing armed intruders, police guidance converges: don’t resist physically, don’t provoke, comply calmly, and observe useful details (number, voices, clothing, vehicle) without staring at the assailants. No possession is worth a life. As soon as possible, call 911: an abduction triggers a priority response, and every minute counts for investigators.

After the assailants leave: the order of priorities
  1. Get to safetyMake sure the assailants have left, free yourself, lock up.
  2. Call 911Report the abduction first: description, direction, vehicle, time.
  3. Get careA blow to the head with loss of consciousness requires a medical assessment.
  4. Preserve the sceneDon’t touch or clean anything: the traces help the investigation.
  5. Seek supportVictim support services (CAVAC in Quebec) and Info-Social 811 for the whole family, children included.

What this scenario reveals

Emotionally charged survival scenarios aren’t only there to test your courage or composure. They shed light on dimensions often neglected in conventional citizen preparedness.

Mental preparation, not just material

Most preparedness resources focus on equipment, water reserves, food or evacuation routes. These elements are essential. But the ability to make a coherent decision under extreme emotional pressure is a skill in its own right — and it can be worked on, in part, through exercises like this one.

Confronting difficult situations mentally in advance means that, if they happen, you are not completely thrown by their brutality. You have already thought it through. You have already gone through part of the cognitive shock outside the crisis.

Cognitive biases in a crisis

Under pressure, several cognitive mechanisms influence decisions, often unconsciously:

  • Decision paralysis: faced with an unacceptable option, the brain may refuse to choose. This freeze has concrete consequences.
  • The protect-the-weakest bias: the instinct to protect the most vulnerable, which can conflict with a logic of collective survival.
  • Initial shock: the first seconds of consciousness after physical trauma are rarely conducive to strategic thinking.
  • Tunnel vision: focusing on a single element of the problem at the expense of an overall view of the situation.

Recognizing these biases doesn’t eliminate them. But having identified them with a clear head can help you spot them faster in a critical moment.

The relational and family dimension

This scenario involves people you love. That is precisely what makes it difficult — and useful. Citizen preparedness rarely builds the emotional dimension into its exercises. Yet in a real situation, it is often this dimension that overrides all prior reasoning.

Thinking through scenarios of this kind as a family — even without going into anxiety-inducing details — can help identify shared values and priorities, and build a form of collective resilience.

Taking your reflection further

This scenario doesn’t call for a single answer. It calls for honest reflection. Here are a few more angles to explore:

  • Have you ever discussed with your family what you would do collectively in a direct threat at home?
  • Does your home have features that would make this kind of intrusion harder or easier?
  • Have you thought about a communication protocol if a family member disappeared or was held against their will?
  • Do you know the local resources available in a criminal emergency — numbers, response times, procedures?

Discussing the scenario as a family

This scenario is most valuable in discussion between adults: what decision would you make, and above all why? What alternatives would you consider? With children, don’t present the scenario itself: talk instead about simple rules (where to hide, who to call, the family password) and reassure them.

Further reading

See basic home safety, children in a crisis, reacting in a crisis: denial, freezing and mental training and our preparedness books.