In this article
  1. In brief
  2. What is composting?
  3. Why compost?
  4. Aerobic or anaerobic?
  5. Who works in the compost?
  6. Browns and greens
  7. Starting a home composter
  8. How long does it take?
  9. What to avoid in a home composter
  10. Special cases
  11. Fixing common problems
  12. Do you need two composters?
  13. Composting in an apartment
  14. Composting and food self-reliance
  15. Successful compost doesn’t need to be perfect
  16. Frequently asked questions

Composting rests on a simple idea: part of a household’s organic matter can go back to the soil instead of ending up in the garbage. Peels, dead leaves, garden waste, brown paper and cardboard become, with a little time and care, a valuable amendment for the vegetable garden, flower beds and planters.

For a household seeking more self-reliance, compost has a double benefit: it reduces what has to be thrown away, and it produces on site something to feed the soil, without depending on a bag of bought potting mix. Composting doesn’t create fertility out of nothing: it recovers what organic matter already contains and returns it to the soil cycle. This guide explains the principles, how to start and maintain a composter, what can and can’t go in it, and how to fix common problems.

In brief

In brief. Good compost needs four ingredients: varied materials, oxygen, moisture and a little heat. Alternate about two to three volumes of “browns” (dead leaves, straw, cardboard) for one volume of “greens” (peels, fresh grass), keep it all as moist as a wrung-out sponge and turn it from time to time. Avoid meat, fish, dairy, fats and droppings from meat-eating animals in a home composter. Compost is ready in a few months to a year, when it is dark brown, crumbly and smells like forest soil.

What is composting?

It is a natural biological process in which microorganisms and small soil organisms gradually break down organic matter. The result is a dark brown, crumbly material that smells like earth: finished compost.

The four conditions for working compost
  1. Balanced materialsA mix of carbon-rich browns and nitrogen-rich greens.
  2. OxygenAeration feeds the organisms that decompose without odour.
  3. MoistureMoist like a wrung-out sponge, never soggy.
  4. HeatBiological activity warms the pile and speeds decomposition.

Piece size matters too: cut or shredded materials offer more surface to decomposers and break down faster.

Why compost?

  • Improve the soil: finished compost improves soil structure and aeration and, depending on soil type, its ability to hold water and nutrients. It supports roots and releases nutrients slowly.
  • Reduce waste: a large share of household garbage is organic. Composting it reduces what goes to landfill.
  • Gain self-reliance: you produce locally, from materials already available, an amendment you would otherwise buy.
  • Feed soil life: earthworms, fungi and beneficial bacteria thrive in soil enriched with compost.

Aerobic or anaerobic?

Home composting relies on organisms that need oxygen. When the pile is well aerated, decomposition is more efficient, odours stay low, the temperature can rise and the material evolves into stable compost.

When the pile lacks oxygen, because it is soggy or compacted, other processes take over: unpleasant rotten-egg or ammonia odours, slimy, compact material. In a garden composter, a strong smell is a sign of imbalance to fix, not a normal stage. Some intentionally oxygen-free methods exist, such as bokashi, a fermentation in a sealed bucket, but they follow their own rules.

Who works in the compost?

A complex biological community: bacteria, fungi, actinomycetes (which give the forest-soil smell), protozoa, mites, springtails, woodlice, beetles and, when conditions allow, earthworms. Their populations change with temperature, moisture, materials and the compost’s maturity. No need to control them: just give them good conditions.

Browns and greens

Browns, rich in carbonGreens, rich in nitrogen
Dead leavesFruit and vegetable peels and scraps
StrawCoffee grounds and paper filters
Small twigsPlastic-free tea bags, tea leaves
Untreated wood chipsFresh grass clippings (in thin layers)
Shredded newspaperGreen garden waste, vegetable tops
Shredded plain brown cardboardSpent flowers
Dry plants and flowersCrushed eggshells (calcium)
Nut shells, untreated sawdust (in small amounts)Herbivore manure (with precautions, see below)

Browns bring carbon and an airy structure; greens bring nitrogen and moisture. The categories are not absolute: a green leaf that has dried becomes more of a brown, and fresh manure, often mistaken for a brown, is rich in nitrogen and behaves more like a green.

What ratio should you use?

A practical rule: about two to three volumes of browns for one volume of greens. It is not an exact formula; adjust by observing. Too many greens: odours, a sticky mass. Too many browns: nothing happens. In Quebec, keep a bag of dead leaves gathered in fall next to the composter: it is the ideal reserve of browns to cover peels all winter and spring.

Starting a home composter

Getting started in four steps
  1. Choose the spotDirectly on soil, well drained, part shade, accessible year-round.
  2. An airy base10 to 15 cm (4 to 6 in) of twigs or straw at the bottom.
  3. AlternateCover each addition of greens with a layer of browns.
  4. AerateTurn with a fork or aerator every one to two weeks.

Choosing the location

Set the composter directly on the ground, so worms and soil organisms can reach it, in a well-drained spot in part shade (full sun dries it out, full shade keeps it cold), easy to reach even in winter and not too far from the kitchen. Keep a reasonable distance from neighbours, the house and any well, and check your municipality’s bylaws; many offer composters at a reduced price.

Which container?

TypeProsCons
Closed plastic binClean, discreet, keeps animals outHarder to turn
TumblerEasy turning, faster compostLimited volume, no soil contact
Wire or pallet enclosureLarge volume, economical, good aerationLess tidy, attracts more animals
Open pileFree, large volumeNeeds space, dries out or gets soggy more easily
Worm binIndoors, in an apartmentSmall volume, needs monitoring

Moisture: a wrung-out sponge

Take a handful and squeeze: a few drops should appear, without running. Too dry, decomposition stops: water lightly and add greens. Too wet, the pile suffocates: add dry browns and turn. A lid protects against heavy rain.

Temperature: useful, not essential

A well-balanced pile of sufficient volume, around 1 m³ (35 cu ft), can heat up noticeably in the centre, which speeds decomposition and destroys some weed seeds and pathogens. A “cold” home composter also works, just more slowly. In a Quebec winter, activity slows or stops: keep adding greens and browns in layers; everything restarts in spring.

How long does it take?

From a few months to about a year, depending on materials, piece size, balance, aeration and season. A regularly turned, well-balanced pile gives compost faster; a pile left alone eventually transforms too, more slowly.

Recognizing finished compost

  • dark brown to black colour;
  • crumbly texture, like potting soil;
  • pleasant forest-soil smell;
  • the original materials are no longer recognizable, except a few hard bits (pits, twigs) that go back into the composter;
  • the pile no longer heats up.

Screen it through wire mesh if needed. Not-quite-finished compost can be used as mulch on the soil surface, but shouldn’t be dug in next to seedlings.

What to avoid in a home composter

MaterialWhy avoid it
Meat, fish, bonesOdours, attracts animals, health risk
Dairy, fats, oils, saucesOdours, slow decomposition
Dog and cat droppings and litterParasites and pathogens that can contaminate a vegetable garden
Diseased plantsDiseases can survive in compost that doesn’t heat up
Weeds gone to seed or invasive (quackgrass, knotweed)They regrow in the compost and the garden
Treated, painted or varnished wood, barbecue charcoal ashChemical contaminants
Glossy, laminated paper, waxed cardboardAdditives, doesn’t break down
Uncertified “compostable” bagsBreak down poorly at home
Pesticide-treated residuesPossible compost contamination

The municipal green bin accepts more

Municipal organic collections, where they exist, compost on a large scale at high temperatures: they often accept meat, fish, dairy and soiled paper. The two systems complement each other: the home composter for peels and garden waste, the green bin for the rest. Check your municipality’s list.

Special cases

What about manure?

Manure from herbivores (horse, cow, goat, sheep, rabbit, poultry) is an excellent nitrogen-rich input. For a vegetable garden, it must be well composted before use, because fresh manure can contain pathogens such as certain E. coli bacteria and burn young roots. Don’t apply it fresh to vegetables eaten raw. Beware of manure from animals fed hay treated with certain persistent herbicides, which can survive composting and harm tomatoes and legumes.

Grass clippings

Rich in nitrogen, they mat and ferment if added in a thick layer. Add them in thin layers mixed with browns, or let them dry first. Better still: leave them on the lawn, which they feed directly (grasscycling). Avoid clippings from lawns treated with herbicides.

Weeds

Young weeds without seeds compost very well. Those carrying seeds or spreading by roots or stems are better put in the green bin, or “drowned” for a few weeks in a bucket of water before composting.

Paper, cardboard and sawdust

Shredded newspaper and brown cardboard are excellent browns, especially in winter. Avoid glossy paper and brightly printed or laminated cardboard. Untreated sawdust goes in small amounts, well mixed, because it compacts and ties up a lot of nitrogen.

Fixing common problems

ProblemLikely causeSolution
Rotten-egg smellToo wet, lack of oxygenAdd dry browns, turn
Ammonia smellToo many greensAdd browns
Nothing breaks downToo dry, too many browns, pieces too big, too coldMoisten, add greens, shred, wait for spring
Fruit fliesExposed peelsAlways cover greens with a layer of browns
Animals (raccoons, rodents)Unsuitable food scraps, open binNo meat or fat, lid, wire mesh under the bin
Compact, slimy massToo much grass, too much waterMix with browns, aerate

Do you need two composters?

It is very practical. The first is the active compost, where new material goes. When it is full, you leave it to mature without adding anything, and start filling the second. While one matures, the other fills, and you harvest more uniform compost.

Composting in an apartment

  • Vermicomposting: a bin of red wigglers (Eisenia fetida) in a corner of the kitchen turns peels into very rich compost, odour-free if well managed. Alternate peels and damp newspaper, without excess citrus or onions, and keep the bin at room temperature.
  • Bokashi: fermentation in a sealed bucket with inoculated bran; the result must then be buried or added to a compost pile.
  • The municipal green bin or a shared composter in your neighbourhood or community garden.

Composting and food self-reliance

For self-reliance, compost is one of the links that closes the loop: what you grow feeds the family, the scraps feed the soil, and the soil feeds the next crops. If the supply of potting mix and fertilizer is disrupted, a household that knows how to compost keeps a local source of fertility. Hardwood ash, in small amounts, also adds potassium and calcium, but makes soil more alkaline: in moderation, and never barbecue charcoal ash. See small-space gardening and 25 crops for a self-reliant garden.

How to use compost

UseIndicative amount
Vegetable garden in springA 2 to 5 cm (1 to 2 in) layer worked into the surface
Planting shrubs or perennialsOne or two shovelfuls mixed into the planting hole
Potting mixAbout one third screened compost, two thirds potting soil
MulchCoarse compost spread around plants
LawnA thin screened layer in spring

Successful compost doesn’t need to be perfect

People often worry about doing it wrong. In reality, organic matter almost always ends up breaking down; you can only speed up or slow down the process. What matters is covering greens with browns, keeping reasonable moisture and turning from time to time.

Quick checklist

  • the composter sits on soil, in part shade, easy to reach;
  • a reserve of browns is close at hand;
  • each addition of greens is covered with browns;
  • the contents are as moist as a wrung-out sponge;
  • you turn it every one to two weeks in season;
  • no meat, fat, dairy or droppings from meat-eating animals;
  • finished compost smells like forest soil.

Frequently asked questions

How long does home compost take?

From a few months to about a year, depending on balance, aeration, piece size and season.

Can you compost in winter in Quebec?

Yes. Activity slows or stops in the cold, but you can keep adding layers of greens and browns. Decomposition resumes in spring.

Does compost attract animals?

Rarely, if you avoid meat, fish, dairy and fats, cover the peels and keep the bin closed.

Can you add citrus and onions?

Yes in a garden composter, in reasonable amounts. In a worm bin, limit them, since worms don’t like them much.

Can compost replace fertilizer?

It feeds the soil slowly and improves its structure. For heavy feeders such as potted tomatoes, a supplementary fertilizer can still be useful.

What if my compost smells bad?

It usually lacks air or has too many greens: add dry browns and turn it. The smell disappears within a few days.