In this article
  1. Why the question of taking someone in always comes up
  2. A concrete scenario: someone shows up
  3. 9 questions to assess whether to take someone in
  4. A few principles for structuring the decision
  5. What this reflection reveals about your preparedness
  6. Further reading
  7. Frequently asked questions

In a prolonged crisis, no group stays frozen forever. Resources run low, skills are missing and people show up at your door. The question is not whether you will one day have to decide whether to take someone in — it is how to make that decision clearly, without haste or naivety.

Why the question of taking someone in always comes up

Even with rigorous planning, a group formed before a crisis will sooner or later face needs it cannot cover. People age, get hurt or die. Some skills were not anticipated. Other founding members may be absent at the wrong moment.

At the same time, long-term food production, maintaining energy systems, caring for livestock or securing a large perimeter require extra hands and expertise. A small group, however well prepared, reaches its physical and operational limits fairly quickly in a lasting crisis.

The opposite can also happen: you find yourself alone or nearly so, and you are the one trying to join an existing group. Either way, the same fundamental questions apply.

Deciding to bring a new person into a group during a crisis is never trivial. It affects the security, resources and cohesion of everyone. It deserves a structured assessment, not an impulsive answer in either direction.

A concrete scenario: someone shows up

Imagine someone approaching your fallback location. Your lookout warned you early enough. After a first exchange at a distance, the situation doesn’t seem hostile. The person is visibly exhausted, says they have been walking for days, and asks to join your group.

It is precisely in this kind of moment — emotionally charged, urgent, complex — that having a framework worked out in advance makes all the difference.

9 questions to assess whether to take someone in

These questions are not a mechanical checklist. They are a framework to go through together, taking into account the context, the state of the group and the immediate stakes.

1. Does this person inspire trust?

Trust cannot be decreed or assessed in a few minutes. There are several levels: tolerating someone’s presence, giving them a task, letting them access your critical resources. The question is not “do you trust them blindly?” but “what level of trust is justified at this stage, and for what?” Observe their behaviour, body language and the consistency of their story. Warning signs count as much as reassuring ones.

2. Do they bring useful skills or resources?

Medical training or experience in mechanics, carpentry, market gardening, electrical work or trapping can be of considerable value to a group. Beyond skills, the person may also bring equipment, supplies or other resources. This assessment must stay realistic: claimed skills are not necessarily real skills. A period of observation or a gradual trial is legitimate.

3. Do you have the resources to take them in?

Every new member has an immediate cost: food, water, space, energy, security. If your supplies are calculated tightly for your current group, an extra mouth to feed changes the equation. That said, the analysis should look at the medium and long term: if this person helps increase your production or operational capacity, the balance can quickly tip the other way. This is not a cold calculation, but an honest assessment of your real capacity.

4. What brought them here?

A person’s account of their journey is a valuable source of information — provided you also listen to what goes unsaid. Where are they from? What have they been through? Were they part of another group before? Were they excluded, and why? The answers can reveal problematic behaviour as much as unexpected skills. They can also tell you about the situation in the areas they crossed.

5. Where is your line between charity and caution?

Helping someone and bringing them into your group are two separate decisions. You can offer one-time help — food, first aid, a night under shelter — without opening your group. This nuance matters: it lets you act humanely without taking a disproportionate risk. Conversely, if your group has an urgent, real need — a critical medical skill, for example — the balance shifts. These two realities should be weighed separately.

6. How well do you already know them?

A complete stranger and a long-time acquaintance don’t represent the same level of risk, but neither guarantees anything. In a crisis, behaviour changes. Someone you knew as reliable in normal times can prove unpredictable under pressure. Conversely, a total stranger can turn out to be trustworthy. Prior knowledge is one factor among others, not a guarantee.

7. Do other members of the group know them?

The person may be known to some members — a long-time friend, a distant relative, a former colleague. These ties can provide valuable information about the person’s character. They can also create tension within the group if opinions differ. It is better to identify these connections explicitly than to let them weigh implicitly on the collective decision.

8. What do the other members of the group think?

A decision to take someone in should not rest on one person, even the group’s leader. Other members have their own observations and readings of the situation, and they will also live with the consequences. A consultation process — even a quick one — strengthens internal cohesion and spreads responsibility for the decision. Strong dissent deserves to be heard, even if it need not be a veto. A unanimous agreement deserves as much scrutiny as a disagreement.

9. What does your gut tell you?

Instinct is not infallible, but it should not be ignored either. It often synthesizes signals that conscious analysis has not yet put into words. The condition for trusting it is simple: your instinct must have proven itself in past situations. If you have a history of biased judgments or impulsive decisions, it may be wiser to rely more on the group’s collective view before acting.

A few principles for structuring the decision

Taking someone in is not all or nothing. There are several positions between “outright refusal” and “full, immediate integration”. A period of observation at the edge of the group, a limited role for a set time or gradual integration are legitimate options that reduce risk while staying open to the possibility.

Distinguish urgency from haste. An urgent situation — a serious injury, a critical medical need — can justify a quick decision. But felt urgency can also be used, consciously or not, to short-circuit collective judgment. Keep your framework even under pressure.

Keep track of your decisions. In a prolonged crisis, your group will make several decisions of this kind. Remembering which criteria worked well — or badly — helps refine the shared framework over time.

What this reflection reveals about your preparedness

The ability to calmly assess whether to take in a stranger during a crisis can’t be improvised on the day. It rests on prior preparation: having discussed these scenarios as a group, agreed on shared principles and thought together about acceptable risk thresholds for your situation.

These conversations — sometimes uncomfortable — are exactly what distinguish a group able to get through a prolonged crisis from one that splinters at the first real test. Having them now, away from pressure, is one of the most practical forms of household preparedness.

The question of taking someone in highlights something broader: a group’s relational and decision-making strength is at least as important as its supplies and equipment. A group that knows how to deliberate together holds up better than one that has simply prepared its logistics well.

Further reading

To practise this kind of decision, read our scout scenario on trust, risk and group decisions, and our article on mutual aid and discretion between neighbours in a crisis.

Frequently asked questions

Should the whole group always be consulted before taking someone in?

Whenever possible, yes. A collective decision reduces the risk of individual error and preserves group cohesion. That said, some emergencies — such as an injured person needing immediate care — can justify a quick decision, provided the terms of their inclusion are reviewed collectively as soon as the situation allows.

Can you help someone without bringing them into the group?

Yes, and the distinction is important. Offering food, care or temporary shelter is a different decision from bringing a person into your structure. Having thought in advance about a “support without integration” procedure — how to do it, how far to go, under what conditions — lets you act without endangering yourself or ending up implicitly committed.

Are claimed skills reliable?

Not necessarily. A person may overestimate their abilities in good faith, or exaggerate them deliberately to be accepted. A gradual trial — watching how they actually work and letting them demonstrate their skills on secondary tasks before giving them critical responsibilities — is a reasonable and respectful precaution.

How do you handle the emotional pressure of this decision?

A visibly distressed person naturally creates emotional pressure. That is exactly why it helps to have discussed these scenarios in advance. When the decision framework is set before the situation arises, it is easier to apply without being overwhelmed. If your group hasn’t had these conversations yet, it is one of the first things to plan.