In this article
This scenario is one of our thinking exercises: a realistic situation, a decision to make, then points to help you reflect. Take a few minutes to imagine what you would do before reading on.
In brief
In brief. When someone clutches their chest after exertion, think heart attack: call 911 in Canada, or 15 or 112 in France, immediately, even if the street is snowed in. Follow the dispatcher’s instructions, help the person sit down, send for a defibrillator, and start CPR if they stop responding and are not breathing normally. Meanwhile, neighbours can clear access for emergency services.
The scenario
Last night brought a snowfall like you have never seen. The storm arrived almost without warning. No problem: you have enough supplies to last a few days, and you still have power. You just need to shovel a path so the dog can go out.
After your morning coffee, you pull on your boots and step outside. The sun on the snow is blinding. The street is completely buried: no plow has come by, and the snow is so deep that nobody has even tried to drive out.
You are not the only one shovelling: across the street, your neighbour is clearing his driveway. You nod to each other. A few minutes later, you see him fall. You laugh at first, thinking he slipped, but you quickly realize he is in trouble.
You cross the street, sinking into the snow. He is lying on the ground, clutching his chest and groaning. Everything points to a heart attack, a well-known risk when shovelling heavy snow. But what can you do? It seems impossible for an ambulance to get through all this snow.
What is your decision?
Before reading on, write down your answers:
- What is the very first thing to do?
- What can you do for your neighbour while waiting for help?
- Who else can you call on, and how?
- What will you do if he loses consciousness?
Points for reflection
Call for help, even in a storm
The essential reflex is to call emergency services immediately: 911 in Canada, or 15 (SAMU) or 112 in France. Do not assume the ambulance cannot come: emergency services have ways of reaching snowed-in streets, can coordinate with a snowplow or send first responders, and the dispatcher will guide you step by step. Put the phone on speaker to keep your hands free.
What to do while waiting
- Help the person sit, leaning back, in a comfortable position, and loosen tight clothing.
- Protect them from the cold: a blanket, a coat, cardboard or a mat underneath to insulate them from the snow.
- Do not let them walk or exert themselves.
- If the dispatcher advises it and they are not allergic, they can chew aspirin (ASA) at the dose indicated.
- If they take prescribed nitroglycerin, help them take it according to their prescription.
- Send someone for an automated external defibrillator (AED) if there is one nearby: a store, an arena, a school, a community centre.
If they lose consciousness
If the person stops responding and is not breathing normally, start cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) immediately: chest compressions in the centre of the chest, about 100 to 120 per minute, pressing down about 5 to 6 centimetres in an adult, without interruption. The dispatcher can guide you. As soon as an AED arrives, turn it on and follow its voice prompts. If several people are present, take turns every two minutes to keep compressions effective.
Mobilizing neighbours
You are not alone on the street. Call for help: one person stays with the victim, another goes for an AED, others clear a path to the street and make the address visible to responders. In the middle of a storm, a few neighbours with shovels can save paramedics precious minutes. This is local mutual aid at its most concrete.
What this scenario tests
| Skill | How to develop it |
|---|---|
| Recognizing a cardiac emergency | Know the signs: chest pain or tightness, shortness of breath, sweating, nausea, pain in the arm, jaw or back; signs can be subtler in women |
| Raising the alarm | Be able to give your exact address and describe the situation calmly |
| CPR and AED | Take a recognized course and renew it regularly |
| Organizing mutual aid | Know your neighbours and who has skills or equipment |
Preventing accidents while shovelling
Shovelling heavy snow is intense exertion, especially in cold weather, and it increases cardiac risk for people who are not very active or who have risk factors. A few precautions:
- warm up for a few minutes and take frequent breaks;
- push the snow rather than lifting it, and take small shovelfuls;
- avoid shovelling right after a big meal or after smoking;
- stop immediately if you feel pain, shortness of breath or discomfort;
- if you have heart disease or risk factors, ask your doctor’s advice and get help.
Offering to help an older neighbour clear snow is also an excellent way to prevent this scenario.
Frequently asked questions
Should you drive the person to the hospital yourself?
Generally, no. Paramedics can start treatment on site and alert the hospital. Transporting someone in cardiac distress through snowed-in streets can delay care and put you in danger. Follow the dispatcher’s instructions.
What if I have never learned CPR?
Do chest compressions anyway: the dispatcher will guide you. Imperfect CPR is far better than none. Then sign up for a course: a few hours are enough to learn the basics.

