In this article
A fifth-floor apartment in Paris and a farm in the Creuse, in rural central France. A condo in Montreal and a house on a country road in Lanaudière, Quebec. All four households can face the same storm, the same heat wave or the same outage. They will not face the same risk, and they will not need the same preparation.
General guides, including 72-hour checklists, speak to an average household that does not exist. This page shows what really changes depending on where you live, first between city and country, then between Quebec and France, and how to take it into account without starting from scratch.
What really changes
The hazard, risk, threat, disaster chain holds the key: risk depends on the hazard, but also on the household’s exposure and vulnerability. Location affects all three.
- The hazards differ. Ice storms and extreme cold weigh heavily in Quebec, wildfires in northern Quebec and southern France, floods in river valleys, industrial accidents near high-risk sites.
- Exposure differs. In the city, you are often sheltered from floods and wildfires, but exposed to heat, congestion and dependence on upper floors and elevators. In the country, you are more exposed to cut-off roads, fallen trees and long outages.
- Vulnerability differs. A well with an electric pump, all-electric heating or a hospital 50 km away make a household more vulnerable. Close neighbours, a wood stove or a grocery store within walking distance make it less so.
- Delays differ. The networks serving the most people are restored first. Country roads, hamlets and the ends of power lines often come last. That is why the page 72 hours: a minimum, not a goal proposes a level of 14 days or more.
The common effects are the same everywhere. What changes is their order, their duration and their severity.
City and country: what differs
| Question | In the city | In the country |
|---|---|---|
| Where does the water come from? | Municipal network, sometimes pumped up to upper floors | Often a well, whose pump stops with the power |
| How is the home heated? | Often electric or central, few backup options in an apartment | More often a wood stove or a possible backup heater, but homes more exposed to cold |
| How long does an outage last? | Usually short, priority networks | Longer, line ends restored last |
| How far are emergency services and care? | Close, but overwhelmed in a crisis | Far, roads sometimes cut off |
| Supplies? | Stores nearby, but emptied quickly | Stores far away, but homes often better stocked |
| Leaving? | Evacuation possible on foot, but roads jammed | A car is essential, sometimes only one road |
| Mutual aid? | Many neighbours, often strangers | Few neighbours, often known |
| What is most often missing | Water, storage space, cool air in summer | Length of self-sufficiency, access to care, communications |
This table describes trends, not rules. A suburb of detached homes often looks like the country for water and heating, and like the city for delays. That is the point of the five questions on the 72-hour page: your water, your heating, distance to services, care, neighbours.
Quebec and France: same principles, different tools
Both sides of the Atlantic share the essentials: civil security is a shared responsibility, and citizens are the first actors in their own safety. But the tools, numbers and habits are not the same.
| Quebec | France | |
|---|---|---|
| Emergency number | 911 | 112, or 15 (medical), 18 (fire), 17 (police) |
| Mobile phone alerts | Québec En Alerte, Quebec’s part of the Canada-wide Alert Ready system. Your phone must be compatible and connected to an LTE or newer network; in silent mode, the alarm may not sound | FR-Alert, in service since June 2022, with no sign-up or app. The alert sounds even in silent mode, but not if the phone is off or in airplane mode |
| Other alert channels | TV, radio, Urgence Québec social media, each municipality’s own tools | About 2,000 sirens, public radio and TV, social media |
| Knowing your local risks | The municipality, first responsible for civil security in its area, and its civil security plan | Géorisques, and the DICRIM prepared by the mayor, which lists risks, instructions, alert channels and shelters |
| Family plan | Family emergency plan (Quebec and Canada) | Family safety plan, and the new individual safety plan |
| Roads and outages | Québec 511, Hydro-Québec | Bison Futé, the local electricity network operator |
| Hazards that often dominate | Cold, ice storms, northern wildfires | Floods, heat, southern wildfires, industrial risks |
Three practical consequences:
- In Quebec, do not rely on your phone alone. Check that your phone receives alerts, do not leave it on silent overnight without another way to be woken, and keep a radio.
- In France, open your town’s DICRIM. In a few pages, it tells you what your town hall has planned, which is rare and valuable.
- On both sides, call your town hall or municipality. Ask where the shelters are and how residents are alerted where you live.
Four households, four preparations
Four examples to see how the same approach leads to different results.
A fifth-floor apartment in Paris
Dominant hazards: heat waves, Seine flooding in some neighbourhoods, outages, accidents or attacks. First domino: heat in summer, water if pressure no longer reaches the upper floors. Priorities: keep one room cool, store water in little space, know your elderly neighbours, decide whether to stay or join family outside Paris. Suggested level: 7 days.
A farm in the Creuse
Dominant hazards: storms, snow and ice, isolation, drought. First domino: electricity, which often stops the water and sometimes the heating. Priorities: an independent source of heat and water, a medical supply, communications that do not depend on a single tower, an arrangement with the nearest neighbours. Suggested level: 14 days or more.
A condo in Montreal
Dominant hazards: ice storms, outages, extreme heat, flooding in some areas. First domino: electricity, and with it heating and the elevator. Priorities: a plan for winter without heat (a room to keep warm, or a place to stay with family), water, a radio, and attention to neighbours who cannot use the stairs. Suggested level: 7 days.
A house on a country road in Lanaudière
Dominant hazards: ice storms, windstorms, cold, wildfires further north, cut-off roads. First domino: electricity, which stops the well pump and often the heating. Priorities: a stove or safe backup heater, a water reserve and a way to treat it, fuel, a properly sized generator if possible, and a plan with the neighbours along the road. Suggested level: 14 days or more.
In all four cases, the foundation is the same: the eight common effects and the core decisions. What changes is the order of priorities and the target duration.
What authorities say, and what the field adds
Official guidance — Know the risks in your region and town, know how you will be alerted, make a family plan and be self-sufficient for at least 72 hours.
PrépaCivile field recommendation — Adapt the level to where you live: 7 days for most urban households, 14 days or more in rural or remote areas, on a well or at the end of a power line. Check in practice that alerts reach you, on your phone and through a second channel.
Field insight — In rural areas, people are often better equipped than in the city, but also more alone when things drag on. In the city, it is the opposite: lots of people around, few supplies and little space. Good preparation does not copy that of someone in another setting: it starts from your own home.
The exercise: your local fact sheet
Twenty minutes, in week 1 or 2 of the 365 Program.
- Do My radar to find the hazards that dominate where you live.
- Find out how you will be alerted. In Quebec, check that your phone receives Québec En Alerte and visit your municipality’s website. In France, open your town’s DICRIM on Géorisques or ask for it at the town hall.
- Note useful places: shelter, hospital, pharmacy, water point, nearest gas station with a generator if you know one.
- Answer the five questions on the 72-hour page (water, heating, distance, care, neighbours) and choose your level.
- Find your first domino, as in the common effects page.
Keep this sheet with your family plan. It changes little, but it changes every time you move.
Frequently asked questions
I live in the suburbs. City or country?
Often a bit of both: city water and stores, but electrically heated homes and car travel. Answer the five questions rather than choosing a label.
I live in France and Quebec depending on the season.
Make two local fact sheets. The family plan (roles, out-of-town contact) stays the same; numbers, alerts and hazards change.
My phone does not receive alerts. What should I do?
Check your emergency alert settings and compatibility with your carrier. Either way, keep a battery or hand-crank radio: it is what remains when the network goes down.
I live in the city and have no storage space.
Aim for the 7-day level with compact formats, rotate supplies through your everyday use, and make up for it with skills (treating water, cooking without power) and mutual aid.
Sources
- Government of Quebec, Québec En Alerte (in French)
- CRTC, Emergency alerts and the National Public Alerting System
- Government of Quebec, Rôles et responsabilités en sécurité civile (in French)
- Government of France, FR-Alert, comment ça marche ? (in French)
- French Ministry of the Interior, Tout savoir sur le dispositif national FR-Alert (in French)
- Géorisques, Know the risks near you (in French)
- Bison Futé, The public road information service
- Government of Quebec, Family emergency plan and emergency kit (in French)
