In this article
- In brief
- An often-overlooked assumption
- Why would someone want to leave?
- Holding someone back: a line not to cross
- Flexibility as a preparedness skill
- Anticipate rather than react
- A departure protocol in practice
- What this scenario reveals about preparedness
- Key points
- Frequently asked questions
- Further reading
Most thinking about preparedness focuses on what comes in: resources, trusted people, safety rules. Far less attention is paid to what goes out, and in particular to the possibility that a member of the household or group deliberately decides to leave.
This scenario is rarely taken seriously. Yet in a prolonged crisis, human tensions do not disappear: they intensify. Understanding this reality is part of honest, realistic preparedness.
In brief
In brief. In a long crisis, an adult may want to leave the group to join a loved one, escape a conflict or simply out of exhaustion. That is their right: holding someone against their will is illegal everywhere and dangerous for everyone. The right response is to anticipate it: talk about it before the crisis, share sensitive information only as needed, plan an organized departure and a way to stay in touch, then reorganize the group.
An assumption often overlooked in planning
Preparedness often relies on a fairly stable picture: a close-knit group, planned resources, defined roles. People anticipate outside threats, such as a break-in, shortages or service interruptions, but rarely internal fractures.
Yet prolonged crises create very trying conditions: chronic stress, cramped living space, constant uncertainty, differences in values or priorities. These factors can profoundly change relationships within a group, even a well-prepared one made up of trusted people.
The question is not whether tensions will arise: in a long crisis, they almost inevitably do. The question is whether you have thought about what you will do if they lead to a split.
Why would someone want to leave?
The instinctive answer would be that no sensible person would leave a safe, well-supplied shelter. But rationality is not the only driver of human decisions, especially under extreme stress and for an indefinite period. Several realistic scenarios are worth considering.
| Reason | What happens |
|---|---|
| Emotional ties outside | An adult child, a partner or a loved one is somewhere else. The person chooses to join them rather than stay in a place that feels safe but cut off from what matters to them. |
| Leadership conflicts | Authoritarian management, disputed decisions or excessive control make the environment unbearable. The constraint people feel becomes heavier than the outside risk. |
| Relationship breakdowns | Marital or family conflicts do not vanish during a crisis; stress often amplifies existing tensions. A separation remains possible and can lead to someone leaving. |
| Differences in values or priorities | Members have very different views of what is acceptable, morally, practically or strategically. Tested over time, these differences can lead to a split. |
| Fatigue and discouragement | After a long period of uncertainty and hardship, some people no longer have the will to go on under current conditions, even if other options look riskier on paper. |
These motivations are rarely purely irrational: they are legitimate human factors. Recognizing them lets you respond with respect rather than suspicion.
Holding someone back: a line not to cross
One argument sometimes comes up in certain discussions: once someone is part of the group, they could no longer leave freely, because they know where the supplies are, the safety rules and the group’s weak points. They would supposedly be a risk.
This argument must be clearly rejected. An adult has the right to leave. Holding them against their will, by force, by threats or by preventing them from going out, is a serious offence in every country (forcible confinement, unlawful detention or kidnapping, depending on the jurisdiction), including during an emergency. It is also morally unacceptable, and that does not change when institutions are overwhelmed.
It is dangerous in practice too: a person who wants to leave and feels like a prisoner poses a far greater risk, to themselves and to the group, than someone who leaves in an organized way. Coercion destroys the trust of every other member, who will wonder what would happen to them in turn.
Remember. The right question is not “How do we stop someone from leaving?” but “How do we make a possible departure as safe as possible for the person leaving and for those who stay?”.
For minor children, the situation is different: their safety is the responsibility of their parents or guardians, and custody decisions follow the usual rules. If parents seriously disagree, contact social or legal services as soon as they can be reached.
Flexibility as a preparedness skill
The best-built plans rely on simple logic: if A happens, we do B. That is a necessary foundation. But real situations do not always follow the expected scenarios, and human factors are among the most unpredictable.
The ability to adapt a plan when something changes, including the make-up of the group, is a skill in its own right. A group that loses a member, for whatever reason, must be able to reorganize its resources, roles and priorities without falling apart: who takes over the departed person’s tasks, how are supplies shared, does the evacuation plan need revising?
Absolute rigidity is rarely an advantage. In real situations, adaptability often counts for more than how perfect the original plan was. That does not mean you should not plan, quite the opposite: planning with room for change, including within the group, produces more robust preparedness.
Anticipate rather than react
The best way to handle this kind of situation is not to improvise under pressure, but to have at least discussed it in advance with the people concerned. A few practical ideas:
- Have frank conversations before the crisis: talk about everyone’s expectations, acceptable limits and scenarios in which someone might want to leave or join another group.
- Share sensitive information on a need-to-know basis: not everyone needs every detail, such as the exact location of all supplies. Sensible information sharing limits risks if someone leaves, without creating a climate of secrecy.
- Define a departure protocol: not to encourage departures, but so that if someone does leave, it happens in conditions that best protect everyone’s safety.
- Honestly assess the group’s dynamics: existing tensions, personalities that struggle under pressure, known disagreements. It is better to identify them before pressure amplifies them.
- Build a culture of trust rather than coercion: a group whose members stay because they choose to generally works better than one held together by fear or obligation.
The techniques in our article on de-escalation in a group during a crisis often help keep tension from turning into a split.
A departure protocol in practice
| Element | Questions to settle in advance |
|---|---|
| Announcement | How does the person tell the group? Is a night to think it over offered, without being imposed? |
| Resources | What can reasonably be given to them (water, food for a few days, a kit, a map) without putting the group at risk? Their personal belongings are returned to them. |
| Route and safety | Which route, at what time, with what information about known dangers? Do we avoid leaving alone at night? |
| Communication | How and when will they send news? Does an out-of-area contact act as a relay? Is a meeting point agreed in case they want to come back? |
| Discretion | What confidentiality rules were agreed from the start, and are they restated without threats? |
| Reorganization | Who takes over their tasks? Do watch rotations, rations or the evacuation plan need to change? |
What this scenario reveals about preparedness
Citizen preparedness is often thought of in terms of material resources: water, food, energy, equipment. These are essential. But the human dimension, cohesion, communication and conflict management, is just as decisive in a prolonged crisis.
A well-supplied group that cannot manage its internal tensions is fragile. Conversely, a group whose members communicate honestly, have realistic expectations of one another and have thought through difficult scenarios will generally be more resilient, even with fewer resources.
The strongest preparedness takes human realities into account as they are, not as we would like them to be. Recognizing that a group member might want to leave is not a sign of failure: it is a sign of realism.
Key points
- Voluntary departures during a crisis are a realistic scenario, not an anomaly to ignore.
- The motivations are rarely irrational: emotional ties, conflict, exhaustion and deep disagreements are legitimate human factors.
- Holding an adult against their will is illegal, morally unacceptable and dangerous for the whole group.
- Anticipating this scenario lets you respond calmly and in an organized way.
- Flexibility and human cohesion are preparedness skills, just like supplies or physical security.
Frequently asked questions
Can you forbid a group member from leaving?
Not if they are an adult. Everyone is free to leave, including during a crisis; holding someone by force is a serious offence. You can, however, suggest time to think it over, share information about the risks and organize the departure in the best possible conditions.
How can you keep tensions from leading to a hasty departure?
Through communication before the crisis: openly discussing expectations, roles, acceptable limits and difficult scenarios. A group that has had these conversations, uncomfortable as they may be, generally gets through periods of tension better.
What if it is an adult child who wants to leave?
An adult child is an autonomous person capable of making their own decisions, including ones you consider risky. Make sure they have the information they need to weigh the risks, give them what you reasonably can to improve their chances and agree on a way to communicate and a meeting point.
Should a crisis plan explicitly cover departures?
Not necessarily formally, but it is useful to have thought about it. Who knows what information? What can be given to someone who leaves? How does the group reorganize if its make-up changes? Addressing these questions in advance avoids improvising under pressure.

